The lack of
anachronisms is often used as evidence
against the possibility of
time travel.
Anachronism
literally means "out of time". It can be any object or event, in
fiction or in the real world, that appears out of place because it
isn't appropriate or is impossible for the time.
In relation
to theories of time travel, the question of anachronisms has been
discussed as possible disproof of (or proof for) the possibility of
travelling in time. If it is possible to travel in time, why isn't
there any historical evidence that people from the future have
visited the past? And why are there no obvious anachronisms in our
own time?
It can be assumed that if time travel is possible at
any future time, that temporal explorers would travel throughout
history, and the longer time travel techniques existed, the more
people would travel. It might be considered inevitable that these
people would leave some anachronistic evidence behind. The time
traveller themselves would likely be a notable anachronism, since
even something as simple as spoken language changes rapidly over
time. The lack now and throughout history of any anachronistic
technology, objects, or ideas could be taken as proof that time
travel does not happen and therefore is not possible. "There are no
anachronisms", this argument goes, "so there never will be any
travellers with time machines".
== Breadcrumb trails and
hidden clues ==
The
corollary of this argument is that if anachronisms
exist, then this might be evidence for time travel. Some people
look at history and cause and effect, and find things which appear
not to have happened in a sensible chronological order, such as
unbelieavble accomplishments or sudden advances in technology or
thought.
A further theory, explored especially by science
fiction and fantasy authors, suggests that time travel may be
monitored for the specific purpose of controlling anachronism; the
suggestion is that in the future there may be a kind of "time
police." This group would control what people were able to do when
they travelled in time, and perhaps be responsible for "correcting"
errors and eddies in the space time continuum, returning history to
its 'pure' path as if it had not been tampered with. This idea is
strongly related to a non-deterministic or "chaos" theory of
history, suggesting that any anachronistic influences would by
nature be destructive, changing everything in the time line to
follow. If such a body of "time police" existed, it would be hard
to imagine that they would perform this task perfectly leaving no
evidence behind, though one may consider that if time travel
techniques were perfected, there would be an infinite number of
opportunities to correct a single change. The "time police" theory
also presents a dramatic example of what is commonly called the
grandfather paradox or the time
loop paradox: if an anachronism in time was in fact corrected, how
would anyone in the future know to go back and correct it? For more
exploration of time paradoxes, see the
time travel article.
Both progressive
and regressive anachronisms could be the result of time travel, but
regressive anachronisms tend to be much stronger proof. If, say,
dinosaurs are found on a remote pacific island, that could be the
result of time travel. But it could equally be that this particular
island has somehow been sheltered from whatever wiped out the rest
of the dinosaurs. By contrast, if Julius Caesar is caught on film
in ancient Rome wearing a pair of Levis, that could only be a
result of time travel (on two counts).
== Other Explanations
==
The scarcity of anachronisms may exist because of "time
police", or because time travel is impossible. However, there are
other (possibly less dramatic) explanations:
Time Travel may
be very difficult. This would make anachronisms either very rare or
non-existent. It might also limit time-travel to larger
organisations who would be more responsible in their uses of the
technology. (because governments and large corporations are known
for their responsibility and integrity.) The human species
may become extinct shortly after the invention of time travel, so
there won't be enough time [sic] to flood the past with tourists.
The technology might also be developed on another planet or even by
another species. Maybe time travel is itself a dangerous
technology? It may not be possible to travel back in time
past the creation of some specific artifact. The Tippler Method is an
example of a method with this kind of limitation. In this case we'd
expect to see no time travellers now, but at soon as the relevant
artifact is constructed we'd expect visitors from the future to be
a fact of life. == Example Anachronisms ==
If the
pyramids were not built
by aliens, must they have
been built with technology from a future civiliation? They're
certainly impressive monuments in both scale and design, but the
Egyptians were skilled
masons with an almost
infinite supply of labour. What about other feats of ancient
engineering?
From the solar calendar that is Stonehenge to the statues of Easter Island, there are
a number of ancient monuments that have raised eyebrows over their
feasability given the technology and government of the time. Did
their builders get a helping hand? How could Leonardo da Vinci
have imagined the helicopter, centuries before it first took off?
But Leonardo's helicopter could not in fact fly, and wasn't a
proper helicopter anyway. Leonardo also had some tank designs:
another temporal anomaly? And what was it that really sent Leonardo
mad? How come the Greeks had a clocklike computer over 2000
years before clockwork's 'natural' development in the 18th Century,
in the shape of the Antikythera mechanism? Perhaps the
Time Police ensured that the secret of clockwork was hidden for
long enough for technology to catch up. After all, the last
mechanism went down in a ship wrecked in the Mediterranean.
The Baghdad
Battery has puzzled people for years. A more fanciful
suggestion is that the fabled island of Atlantis was one giant anachronism, and it was
drowned in an attempt to hide this "fact". Some people argue
that these examples and others show that there have been careless
Time Travellers and show that Temporal Secret Agents have been here
on containment and damage limitation missons. These are said to be
the smoking guns of the ultimate conspiracy theory.
== History
==
<!--- This section is required under the GFDL where we have
imported text from a third party under the terms of the GFDL..
Please only edit this section as allowed for by the GFDL. -->
2002-3: Published by Wikimedia, Edited by Wikipedia contributors,
Entitled Anachronism and time travel 2002: Published
by h2g2, Written by
a girl called
Ben, Entitled Hellmans' Anachronism: an
hypothesis about historical proof of future time travel