Aristarchus On the Sizes and Distances: Wikis

Note: Many of our articles have direct quotes from sources you can cite, within the Wikipedia article! This article doesn't yet, but we're working on it! See more info or our list of citable articles.

Encyclopedia

Aristarchus's 3rd century BC calculations on the relative sizes of, from left, the Sun, Earth and Moon, from a 10th century CE Greek copy

On the Sizes and Distances [of the Sun and Moon] (Περὶ μεγεθῶν καὶ ἀποστημάτων [ἡλίου καὶ σελήνης]) is the only extant work written by Aristarchus of Samos, an ancient Greek astronomer who lived circa 310 BC - 230 BC. In this work, he calculates the sizes of the Sun and Moon, as well as their distances from the Earth in Earth radii.

Symbols

His method relied on several observations:

• The apparent size of the Sun and the Moon in the sky (this is easy to measure).
• The size of the Earth's shadow in relation to the moon during a lunar eclipse (this is harder to measure, but can be done with a little effort)
• The angle between the Sun and Moon when the Moon is exactly half lit is very close to 90 degrees (this is very hard to measure precisely enough, and is the main reason why the method is not all that accurate)

This construction uses the following variables:

Symbol Meaning
S Distance to the Sun
L Distance to the Moon
D Distance to the vertex of Earth's shadow cone
n d/l, a directly observable quantity during a lunar eclipse
φ Directly observed.
x S/L, which is derived from φ

Half-lit Moon

Aristarchus began with the premise that, when the moon was exactly half-lit, it forms a right triangle with the Sun and Earth. By observing one of the other angles in this right triangle, the ratio of the distances to the Sun and Moon could be deduced using a form of trigonometry.

From the diagram and trigonometry, we can calculate that

$\frac{S}{L} = \frac{1}{\cos \varphi} = \sec \varphi.$

The diagram is greatly exaggerated, because in reality, S = 390L, and φ is extremely close to a right angle (only 10′ shy). Aristarchus determined φ to be a thirtieth of a quadrant (in modern terms, three degrees) less than a right angle: in current terminology, 87°. Trigonometric functions had not yet been invented, but using geometrical analysis in the style of Euclid, Aristarchus determined that

$18 < \frac{S}{L} < 20.$

In other words: that the distance to the Sun was somewhere between 18 and 20 times greater than the distance to the Moon. This value (or values approximately close to it) was accepted by astronomers for the next two thousand years, until the invention of the telescope permitted a more precise estimate of solar parallax.

He also reasoned that as angular size of the Sun and the Moon were the same, but the distance to the Sun was between 18 and 20 times further than the Moon, the Sun must therefore be 18-20 times larger.

Lunar eclipse

Aristarchus then used another construction based on a lunar eclipse:

By similarity of the triangles, $\frac{D}{S} = \frac{t}{s-t} \$ and $\ \frac{d}{t} = \frac{D-L}{D}.$

Since the apparent sizes of the Sun and Moon are the same, it follows that $\frac{L}{S} = \frac{\ell}{s}$. Now

$\frac{D}{L} = \frac{t}{t-d}, \frac{D}{S} = \frac{t}{s-t} \Rightarrow \frac{L}{S} = \frac{t-d}{s-t} \Rightarrow \frac{\ell}{s} = \frac{t-d}{s-t} \Rightarrow 1 - \frac{t}{s} = \frac{t}{\ell} - \frac{d}{\ell} \Rightarrow \frac{t}{\ell} + \frac{t}{s} = 1 + n.$

We can rewrite several variables in terms of x:

$\ell=\frac{s}{x}$, and $s=\ell x.$

Combining this with the previous equation gives:

$\frac{tx}{s} + \frac{t}{s} = n + 1 \Rightarrow \frac{t}{s} = \frac{1+n}{1+x} \Rightarrow \frac{s}{t} = \frac{1+x}{1+n}$
$\frac{t}{\ell} + \frac{t}{\ell x} = n+1 \Rightarrow \frac{t}{\ell} = \frac{1+n}{1+x} x$

These give the radii of the sun and moon entirely in terms of observable quantities. Along with a value for the apparent size of the sun and moon (in degrees), these formulae give the distances to the Sun and Moon in terrestrial units:

$\frac{L}{t} = \left( \frac{\ell}{t} \right) \left( \frac{180}{\pi \theta} \right)$
$\frac{S}{t} = \left( \frac{s}{t} \right) \left( \frac{180}{\pi \theta} \right)$

It is unlikely that Aristarchus used these exact formulae, since he would have lacked a precise value for π. However a simple approximation π = 3 will incur in a relative error smaller than 5%, well below experimental errors in measurements at the time.

These formulae are likely a good approximation to those of Aristarchus.

Results

His values, then, are computed as:

n n/a 2 2.587
θ n/a 1 0.259
s / t (1 + x) / (1 + n) 6.67 109
$t/\ell$ x(1 + n) / (1 + x) 2.85 3.67
L / t $(\ell/t)(180/\pi$θ) 20 60.32
S / t (L / t)(S / L) 380 23,500

The error in this calculation comes primarily from the poor values for x and θ. The poor value for θ is especially surprising, since Archimedes writes that Aristarchus was the first to determine that the Sun and Moon had an apparent diameter of half a degree. This would give a value of θ = 0.25, and a corresponding distance to the moon of 80 earth radii, a much better estimate.

A similar procedure was later used by Hipparchus, who estimated the mean distance to the moon as 67 earth radii, and Ptolemy, who took 59 earth radii for this value.

Known copies

• Library of Congress Vatican Exhibit (see previous picture).

Works cited

• Heath, T. L.. Aristarchus of Samos. Oxford, 1913. This was later reprinted, see (ISBN 0-486-43886-4).
• van Helden, A. Measuring the Universe: Cosmic Dimensions from Aristarchus to Halley. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Pr., 1985. ISBN 0-226-84882-5.