Blogebrity was an internet project which was born
in May of 2005 as a contest entry, and nevertheless managed to have
a real-world impact upon the
blogosphere.
The website purports to be a
sneak preview of a magazine that
may be launching in the
fall of 2005 which would focus upon the lifestyles of
bloggers. The most controversial
aspect of the project was an inclusion of a list of
A-list, B-list, and C-list bloggers.
This list proved to be very controversial among bloggers. Many
of the bloggers named on the list discussed acknowledged their
status on their own blogs, often using a tone that mocked the
concept while still expressing pride in their own inclusion. Many
consider it absurd to dedicate a glossy print magazine to the
lifestyles of such non-glamorous (and in some cases,
non-photogenic) subjects.
One reason that it received such
scrutiny may be because there is not yet a reliable metric for
measuring the popularity of blogs, akin to
Nielsen ratings,
Bestseller lists,
or
Box office
weekend champions. While sites such as
Technorati.com or
Alexa.com provide
some indications of relative popularity, there doesn't yet exist an
authoritative ordinal ranking of blog popularity. (Part of the
problem is that many blogs do not have their own domain, and many
ratings services do not track popularity at the subdomain level.)
For many of the bloggers name-checked, this was the first time they
had been included on such a list, and they reacted (some say
overreacted) accordingly.
In June, Contagious Media (the group
behind the infamous
'Black
People Love Us' website) revealed that the project was created
by both
Kyle
Bunch, and
Jeremy Hermanns, with editorial direction
provided by
Greg
Johns, as their entry in a competition to determine which
Internet meme could generate the most web traffic without any
advertising. By targeting bloggers for attention, many bloggers
ended up linking to their page, helping their prospects in the
contest.
Although Blogebrity only ended up in fifth place,
because of its subject matter, it ended up receiving attention
among opinion-makers and early adopters disproportionate to its
actual significance.
Even though the list was largely subjective
in construction, and was designed to gain attention rather than to
provide objective information, it still is useful as a snapshot of
who the most popular bloggers were in May of 2005. Although many of
the bloggers on the list would disagree about who would really
qualify as an A-lister, there is a consensus that the list does
represent many of the most popular and influential figures in the
blogosphere.
A-list bloggers
Rafat Ali Eric Alterman (Altercation) Ann Althouse Chris Anderson
Heather
Armstrong (Dooce)
Andy Baio
John
Battelle Duncan
Black Rebecca Blood Sean Bonner (Metroblogging) Stowe Boyd Zach Braff Rick Bruner Stewart
Butterfield Jason Calacanis Heather Champ
Jen Chung
Tom Coates
Jessica Coen
(Gawker) Ed Cone Henry Copeland
Ana Marie
Cox (Wonkette)
Mark Cuban
Adam Curry
Drew Curtis
(Fark.com)
Anil Dash
Jason
DeFillippo (Metroblogging) Nick Denton (Gawker Media) Nick DePlume
Hossein Derakhshan (Hoder) Jake Dobkin Cory Doctorow Matt Drudge (Drudge Report)
John Dvorak
John
d'Addario Caterina Fake Brad Fitzgerald (incorrectly
named, intended to refer to Brad Fitzpatrick) Mark
Frauenfelder Neil Gaiman Dan Gillmor Seth Godin Uncle Grambo Matt Haber Steve Hall Ben Hammersley Matt Haughey (Metafilter) Hugh Hewitt John Hinderaker
Meg
Hourihan Arianna Huffington Shel Israel Joi Ito Xeni Jardin (Boing Boing) Jeff Jarvis Joel Johnson Scott Johnson
Mickey Kaus
(Kausfiles)
Zach Klein
Jason
Kottke Scott Lapatine J.D. Lasica Ken Layne Loic Le Meur Lawrence Lessig Mark Lisanti
Bob Lutz
(Fastlane)
Hugh
MacLeod Rob
Malda Om
Malik Michelle Malkin Josh Marshall
(Talking Points Memo) Declan McCullagh
Judith
Meskill Paul Mirengoff (Power Line) Markos Moulitsas
(Daily Kos)
Craig
Newmark B.L. Ochman Dave Pell Glenn Peoples Jonah Peretti David Pescovitz
Tony Pierce
Chris
Pirillo Glenn Reynolds (Instapundit) Jim Romenesko
Jay Rosen
Blake Ross
Steve Rubel
Josh Rubin
Joshua
Schachter Robert Scoble (Scobleizer) Doc Searls Clay Shirky Choire Sicha David Sifry Bill Simmons (The Sports Guy)
Roger L.
Simon
Kevin Sites
Rex Sorgatz
Elizabeth
Spiers Lockhart Steele Biz Stone Andrew Sullivan Tig Tillinghast
Phillip
Torrone Michael Totten Mena Trott Wil Wheaton Evan
Williams Dave
Winer James Wolcott Matthew Yglesias
Jeremy
Zawodny Jeffrey ZeldmanB-list bloggers
Ace Joshua Albertson
Dean Allen
Greg Allen
Jay Allen
Jay Allen John Amato Mehrdad
Aref-Adib Aaron Bailey Stephen Baker Rosecrans
Baldwin Bruce / Hulk Banner Nick Barat La Shawn Barber
John
Perry Barlow Ted Barlow Cameron Barrett Eve Batey Greg Beato Russell Beattie
Belle de
Jour Erin Bennett Erik Benson Cory Bergman
Alex Blagg
Tim Blair
BoiFromTroy
Allison
Bojarski Rachelle Bowden Chris Bowers
Douglas
Bowman Nick Bradbury Susannah Breslin
Harry
Brighouse Jake Bronstein Brooklyn Vegan
Ben Brown
Jerry Brown
Marc Brown
Andy Budd
John Campea
Marc Canter
Captain Ed
Blair
Carswell Michele Catalano Dan Cederholm
Josh
Chafetz Brad
Choate Andy
Clarke Juan
Cole Caryn Coleman Amanda Congdon J.P. Connolly Marc Cooper Jim Coudal Brian Crecente
Jessa
Crispin Adriana Cronin A.J. Daulerio Mike Davidson
Paul
Davidson Daniel Davies Joe Dawson Perry de
Havilland Steve Delahoyde Chris Doelle
Daniel
Drezner Kevin
Drum Drunken Stepfather Jonathan Dube
Esther
Dyson Stephen Elliott Warren Ellis
Ernie Dean Esmay Susan Everett
Sally
Falkow Henry Farrell Maria Farrell Mike Finkel Seth Finkelstein
Luke Ford
Jason Fried
Brad
Friedman David Galbraith Joe Gandelman
Jesse James Garrett Taegan Goddard
Seth
Goldstein Garrett Graff Heather Green Stephen Green
Philip
Greenspun Robert Greenwald John Gruber David Gutowski
Phil Gyford
Rex Hammock
David Heinemeier Hansson
Eszter
Hargittai David Hauslaib Heather
Havrilesky Heather Michael
Heilemann Perez Hilton Bill Hobbs Neville Hobson John Holbo Adrian Holovaty Ben Huh Jon Hurwitz Shaun Inman David Isenberg
Joseph
Jaffe [[JC (music [for robots])]] Jessica Charles Johnson
Dave
Johnson Steven B. Johnson Dave Johnston
James
Joyner Justin Leander Kahney Phillip Kaplan
Joe Katzman
Walter
J. Keegan Niall Kennedy Jeff Koga Andrew Krucoff Larry Kudlow
Jim
Kunstler James Lileks Matt Linderman Christopher
Locke Carlo Longino Karina Longworth
Tristan
Louis Colbert
Low Derek
Lowe Maddox
Amit
Malhotra Black Mamba Jon Mandle Manhattan Transfer Merlin Mann Manolo the
Shoeblogger Amanda Marcotte [[Mark (music [for
robots])]] Mike
Masnick Tucker
Max Ross
Mayfield Bunny McIntosh Gordon McLean
Susan
Mernit Moxie
Matthew
Mullenweg Ron Mwangaguhunga Dave Navarro
Dave
Navarro Shane Nickerson Chris Nolan Montagu Norman
Scott Ott
Steve
Outing Slugger O'Toole Frank Paynter
Chelsea
Peretti Matthew Perpetua Eliot Phillips
Mark
Pilgrim Tim
Porter Jerry Pournelle Derek Powazek
Shelley
Powers Preshrunk John Quiggin Daniel Radosh Scott Rafer RageBoy Raymi the Minx
Mack Reed
Dong Resin
Eric Rice
Jennifer
Rice Emmanuelle Richard Duncan Riley
Sigurd
Rinde Riverbend Claire Robertson
Lindsay
Robertson Kevin Roderick Scott Rosenberg
Alex Ross
RP
Rude Pundit
Steve
Safran Felix Salmon Jason Santa
Maria Sarah Bob Sassone Scaramouch Mark Schmitt Michele Seiler
Catherine
Seipp Kevin
Shay Dave
Shea Harry Shearer Eliot Shepard Paul Shirley
Micah Sifry
Ryan Singer
David
Sirota Rachel Sklar Robin Sloan Spencer Sloan Kevin
Smith S.K.
Smith
Michael Sonnenschein Josh Spear Mike Spinelli
Joel
Spolsky Carl Steadman Brian Stelter Bruce Sterling
Greg Storey
Ben
Sullivan Neil Sutherland Nikola Tamindzic
Jesse
Taylor TDavid
Terry
Teachout Thigh Master Matt Thompson TMF TML Dan Tobin Tom Tomorrow Jason Toney Andre Torrez Gina Trapani
Jean-Paul Tremblay Trent Emily Turrettini
Jon Udell
Jeffrey
Veen Joel
Veitch Vince Veneziani Maria Villar
Khoi Vinh
Eugene
Volokh Miu von Furstenberg Waiter Rant Simon Waldman
David
Weinberger Matt
Welch Jackson West Oliver Willis Fred Wilson Steph Wilson
Andrew
Womack Jeremy Wright Zeyad Claire ZulkeyC-list bloggers
The
following is a selective sample of the much larger list.
Mike Bell
Russell
Brown Margaret Cho Brad DeLong Guido Fawkes Brian Flemming
Chris
Franklin Steve Garfield Matthew Good - Singer from Canada, who was lead singer of
Matthew Good Band Francis Heaney - Author of Holy
Tango of Literature[492] John Hill Dennis Hollingsworth
Molly
Holzschlag Dave
Hyatt Matt
Jones Steve Jurvetson Gordon Keith
Mike Kelley
Jason
Kenney Harry Knowles Tommy Lasorda - Blog hosted by
Major League Baseball[493] Kevin Lynch Tom Maguire Robert May Piers Morgan Rosie O'Donnell
Phil Plait
Jonathan Schwartz (Sun
Microsystems) Jessica Stover (Jessica's Crush on
AOL)External links
The official list Article
explaining hoax Final standings of
contest Blogebrity
interview