For practicing Buddhists, references to "dharma" or
dhamma
in the singular, particularly as "the" Dharma, is used to mean the
teachings of the Buddha, and is sometimes referred to as the
Buddha-Dharma by other non-Buddhist schools of thought.
Dharma is the universal law of nature and to call it
Buddha-Dhamma suggests that other kinds of Dharma may exist. But
this is not so, there is only one Dharma.
The
Dharma traditions of (
Buddhism,
Hinduism,
Jainism) stemmed from
Arya or
Vedic
tradition with their own interpretation of what that tradition is.
Buddhism does not regard Vedic scripture or any scriptures,
including there own, as literal, indisputable or "holy and divine".
Of course, this does not mean scriptures are not respected for what
they teach or represent.
Indian Buddhist tradition categorized
all non-buddhist schools of thought as "
Pasanda"
(Pasanda means to throw a noose or
pasha -- since these
schools foster wrong view which tend to bind and ensnare rather
than free the mind). The difference between the schools of thought
are outlined in the
Saamannaphala Sutta of the
Digha
Nikaya.
Jainism
has also been suggested that the influence of
Jain culture and philosophy in ancient Bihar may
have given rise to Buddhism. Buddhist scriptures describe various
penances (
tapas) undertaken by Gautama Siddhartha which
appear identical to Jain penances (e.g., cupping the hands to
consume alms, plucking of hair, the penance by five fires, etc. ).
These penances were later renounced by Gautama as activities not
leading to
Nirvana
(Final Liberation). Buddhist writings reflect that Jainism was an
already established faith — rather than a newly founded
or reformist one — by the time Buddha lived. Early
Buddhists posited the existence of 24 previous Buddhas (Buddhas who
walked the earth prior to Siddhartha Gautama, as established in the
Buddhist text
Mahavanso 1:100:1 among others) many of
whose names are identical to those of the 24 Jain
Tirthankaras and other traditional Jain figures.
Suggesting close correlations between the teachings of the Jains
and Buddha, the
Majjhima Nikaya relates dialogues between
Buddha and several members of the
Nigantha (Jain)
community, sometimes resulting in the latter's acceptance of Buddha
as a teacher. (See also
Jainism and
Jainism and
Buddhism)
In many instances, both philosophies continue
to share similar Prakrit terminology for important themes and
teachings but may differ significantly in interpretation and
meaning. This method of teaching adopted by the Buddha points to
the pragmatic aspect of Buddha's style of teaching wherein the
Buddha uses words and terms that are familiar to the audience
instead of introducing new and complex technical jargon. In this
way, Buddhism sought to appeal to a broad
audience.
Jainism is
an ancient religion and school of thought that predates Buddhism.
One of its two most revered teachers,
Mahāvīra (
599 -
527
BCE according to Jains, though some scholars prefer 549-477
BCE<sup id="fn_1_back">
1</sup>), was possibly a senior contemporary of
the Buddha whose philosophy, sometimes described as
dynamism or
vitalism, was a blend of the earlier Jain
teacher
Pārśvanātha's (877-777 BCE) order and the
reforms instituted by Mahavira himself. (The
Majjhima
Nikaya relates an incident wherein a disciple brings Buddha
the news that the Nigantha Nattaputta, i.e. Mahavira, had died,
thereby suggesting the latter's seniority.) Debates between
Buddhists and Jains are recorded in Jain texts, and dialogues
between Jains and the Buddha are included in Buddhist texts. (See
also the "Origins" section, above.)
Hinduism
Main
article Gautama Buddha in
HinduismBuddhism is categorized under the
Shraman
Tradition ( ) of modern
Indian
philosophy, rather than the Brahmanical or priestly
interpretation of
Vedic Tradition ( ) that is
followed by Brahmanical or priest based schools of
Hinduism, where the priest holds
himself as the interpretor and giver of Dharma.
In Brahmanical
Hinduism, different philosophies within Indic traditions are
classified by Brahmin priests either as
Astika or
Nastika, that is, philosophies which either affirmed
the
Vedas as divinely
revealed scriptures or else regarded them as fallible human
inventions. According to this tradition, Buddhism is one of
Nastika schools by
priests. The term "Hinduism" is applied to
Astika schools or believed in the
Sanatana
Dharma.
The relationship between Hinduism and Buddhism
should not be seen as an analogue of the relationships between
Judaism, Christianity and Islam. Unlike Abrahamic religions, Indic
dharmas don't require exclusive allegiance and unquestioning
acceptance. The relationship Hinduism and Buddhism is best
understood as an analogue of the relationship between competing
theories in modern day physics. There is fierce debate between the
competing schools in physics but they don't to kill each other. Nor
do the physicists require an unquestioning acceptance from their
students. It is possible that students will change their ideas with
time.
The relationship between Hinduism and Buddhism (in fact
between different schools in Indic traditions) is exactly the same:
they are rival competing schools of thought. Each individual has
the choice to pick either school and philosophers in each school do
their best to convince people.
Most Hindus, even if they do not
agree with the Buddhists, deeply revere the Buddha for his utter
renunciation and for the remarkable person that he was. In fact,
the Bhagavata Purana, one of the most important texts of the
Hindus, considers the Buddha an incarnation of Vishnu. There can be
no higher testament to the Buddha's holiness than this. However,
some Puranas, written by priests as well, also claim that Vishnu
used his incarnation as the Buddha to deceive the unorthodox for
his own reasons.
Buddha Purnima, a festival celebrating the
birth of Gautama Buddha, is one of the most popular Hindu
festivals.
See also
SikhismBuddha as an Avatara of
VishnuGod in BuddhismVegetarianism in
BuddhismExternal Links:
Gandhi and Lord
Buddha Are Buddhists
Hindu?