College Works Painting is an
American house painting
company that offers business management
internships for college students. College
Works Painting's parent company is
National
Services Group.<hr>
Because College Works Painting
provides college students with business experience by having the
student establish and run a house painting business, interns and
customers of College Works Painting have mixed experiences with the
process: both intern and customer satisfaction is tightly linked to
the quality of the work performed by the painters recruited by the
intern. Each intern takes part in both intensive classroom and in
the field training. Depending on one's perspective, it is either
good or bad (according to the student or consumer, respectively)
that the internship gives real world work experience by providing
students with the opportunity to succeed as well as to fail--both
in the quality of the paint job as well as in the quality of the
customer service provided.
The company advertises a 97% customer
satisfaction rate in its client manual and uses this as a main
selling point. This statistic may be questionable, however, because
many employees share stories of dissatisfied customers. Some
problems may include overspray from the paint sprayers (paint on
doors, windows, walkways, etc.) and inability of branch managers to
start or finish paint jobs at the contracted time. Customers may
question the ethics of the company after they are through with
their experience. As of August 5th, 2005, the third result on
Google for “College Works Painting” is a disappointed customer’s
experience
[40], with
a link to an ex branch manager who also feels as though he was
exploited by the company
[41].
The ethics of
the company can come under question from employees. Branch managers
are told that the average summer intern earns about $10,000. This
statistic may be skewed, however; it may be the average for the
minority of branch managers that make it through the program. The
average may be far lower because the company experiences a high
dropout rate for branch managers. Some states have experienced
dropout rates of about 75%. Most who drop out actually lose money,
mainly due to money spent on gas. Branch managers may quit for many
reasons, but some of the most common reasons can include
questioning the ethics of the company, inability to prevent
painters from quitting without notice, the extremely high level of
stress, the unlikelihood of profits, and loss of a social life.
Painters also tend to question the ethics. The main problem for
painters is that the company pays them not an hourly wage, but a
predetermined amount of money for each paint job. This amount of
money is determined by the branch manager’s estimation of how long
the job will take to complete multiplied by the hourly wage for
each estimated hour. Branch managers may underestimate how long
jobs will take; this makes selling the job easier because a lower
price is offered to the customer. As a result, painters can end up
earning minimum wage for jobs.
In the past, the company has
faced several potential lawsuits concerning labor laws. Many
painters feel as though they should be paid more money when they
become aware that their paint jobs have been underbudgeted; instead
of earning the typical nine dollars per esimated painting hour,
they often end up earning minimum wage because jobs take much
longer to complete than estimated. Branch managers have threatened
to sue as well. Many feel they they should be compensated and paid
at least minimum wage for all the hours they have put in; many
branch managers' final profits come out to less than minimum wage
for the number of hours they have worked.
References<hr>
National Services Group
Official Site College Works
Painting Official Site<p> A
Dissatisfied Customer Another Dissatisfied
Customer An ex Branch Manager's
Thoughts