Fan death: Wikis

  
  
  

Note: Many of our articles have direct quotes from sources you can cite, within the Wikipedia article! This article doesn't yet, but we're working on it! See more info or our list of citable articles.

Encyclopedia

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

An urban legend states that when operated in closed rooms, electric fans cause sudden death, suffocating victims by stealing their oxygen.

Fan death is a putative phenomenon generally accepted only in South Korea, in which an electric fan left running overnight in a closed room can cause the death of those inside. Fans sold in Korea are equipped with a timer switch that turns them off after a set number of minutes, which users are frequently urged to set when going to sleep with a fan on.[1]

While the prevalent explanations given by lay Koreans, such as suffocation or hypothermia, are generally incorrect, this does not render the phenomenon itself fallacious; an electric fan running directly on a human body in a hot, enclosed room can accelerate hyperthermia, although this could only occur in a humid atmosphere at temperatures near or exceeding body temperature (such as indoors in the summertime).

Contents

Erroneous beliefs

The specifics behind belief in the myth of fan-death often offer several explanations for the precise mechanism by which the fan kills. However, as explained below, none of these beliefs stand up to logical or scientific scrutiny. Examples for possible justifications of belief in fan death are as follows:

  • That an electric fan creates a vortex, which sucks the oxygen from the enclosed and sealed room and creates a partial vacuum inside. This explanation violates the principle of conservation of matter, as indoor fans are not nearly powerful enough to change the air pressure by any significant amount.
  • That an electric fan chops up all the oxygen particles in the air leaving none to breathe. This explanation violates mass conservation and well-known properties of molecules and gases, particularly that known breakdown energy of oxygen molecules lies in the ultraviolet range. It also ignores the nearly universal human tendency to wake up whilst being suffocated in a moment of sleep. Moreover, the theory makes no justifications for how and why a person will not suffocate whilst awake in a room which contains an operating fan.
  • The fan uses up the oxygen in the room and creates fatal levels of carbon dioxide. An electric motor does not function by combustion; unlike a candle, the electric motor consumes energy supplied by the electricity, not from a fuel. The fan motor's commutator does produce a small amount of ozone during normal operation. Ozone can be fatal in high concentrations but any normal room would never allow the gas to build up to lethal levels.
  • That if the fan is put directly in front of the face of the sleeping person, it will suck all the air away, preventing one from breathing. This explanation ignores both the fact that a fan attracts as much air to a given spot as it is removing from it, and the fact that most people point a fan towards themselves when using one, which causes air to move past the face but does not change the amount of air present. Fan death is frequently cited when police detectives are unable to determine cause of death.
  • That fans contribute to hypothermia, or abnormally low body temperature.[2] As the metabolism slows down at night, one becomes more sensitive to temperature, and thus supposedly more prone to hypothermia. If the fan is left on all night in a sealed and enclosed room, believers in fan death suppose that it will lower the temperature of the room to the point that it can cause hypothermia. Empirical measurements will show, however, that the temperature in the room does not fall, at least not due to the fan; if at all, it should rise slightly because of friction and the heat output of the fan motor, but even this is generally not significant. Fans actually make one cooler by increasing the convection around a person's body so that heat flows from them to the air more easily, and by the latent heat of vaporization as perspiration evaporates from the body. However, there is no scientific study which indicates that this effect would be sufficient to cause hypothermia unless the temperature were already very low.
Electric fans sold in Korea are equipped with a "timer knob" switch, which turns them off after a set number of minutes: perceived as a life-saving function, particularly essential for bed-time use.
  • That fans contribute to prolonged asphyxiation due to environmental oxygen displacement or carbon dioxide intoxication.[3][2][4][5] In the process of human respiration, inhaled fresh air is exhaled with a lower concentration of oxygen gas (O2), and higher concentration of carbon dioxide gas (CO2), causing a gradual reduction of O2 and buildup of CO2 in a completely unventilated room.[6] Other indoor sources of carbon dioxide include burning fossil fuels, such as a gas-fueled water heater, and seepage through foundations in areas of high CO2 soil content.[7] Carbon dioxide is a colorless, odorless gas, and because it weighs 1.5 times more than normal air,[8] it tends to concentrate toward the floor,[5] depending on temperature and air currents. In South Korea, some people sleep on traditional floor mats, called yos, while others prefer western-style beds, and floor vents may be absent when ondol radiant underfloor heating is employed.[9] According to The Straight Dope website run by the Chicago Reader newspaper, asphyxiation is an unlikely cause of fan death because "few rooms are totally sealed, and the fan would tend to keep CO2 and other gases well mixed."[3]
  • That fans directly on the body deprives "skin-breathing," leading to suffocation.

South Korean government position

The Korea Consumer Protection Board (KCPB), a South Korean government-funded public agency, issued a consumer safety alert in 2006 warning that "asphyxiation from electric fans and air conditioners" was among South Korea's five most common seasonal summer accidents or injuries, according to data they collected.[10] Also included among the five hazards were air conditioner explosions and sanitation issues, including food poisoning and opportunistic pathogens harbored in air conditioners. The KCPB actually published the following:

If bodies are exposed to electric fans or air conditioners for too long, it causes [the] bodies to lose water and [causes] hypothermia. If directly in contact with [air current from] a fan, this could lead to death from [an] increase of carbon dioxide saturation concentration [sic] and decrease of oxygen concentration. The risks are higher for the elderly and patients with respiratory problems. From 2003 [to] 2005, a total of 20 cases were reported through the CISS involving asphyxiations caused by leaving electric fans and air conditioners on while sleeping. To prevent asphyxiation, timers should be set, wind direction should be rotated and doors should be left open.

Hyperthermia through electric fan use

Whenever conditions are present which cause heat exhaustion or heat stroke, it is important to realize that a fan does not lower air temperature. It is unsafe to rely on a fan to relieve heat stroke. In fact, technically, fans actually raise air temperature, since their motors produce heat, though by extremely small amounts that would be far from showing up on thermometers. In most conditions fan use will reduce body temperature through evaporation, but it does so at the cost of body fluids, which can increase health risk. Once the body is completely dehydrated and loses the mechanism to control body temperature, the risk of hyperthermia is dramatically elevated. Particularly vulnerable are infants, the elderly and the intoxicated. There are cases of extreme heat and humidity where a fan can actually push heat onto the human body, but the circumstances where moving air exaerbate the problem are extremely unlikely.

Research suggests that fan use may be a contributing factor in heat-related deaths such as fatal cases of hyperthermia.[11] A U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association advises that "although the use of fans may increase comfort at temperatures less than 90°F (less than 32.2°C), fans are not protective against heatstroke when temperatures reach greater than or equal to 90°F (greater than or equal to 32.2°C) and humidity exceeds 35%,"[11] and provides a similar but simpler warning to the public on their website.[12] These temperature and humidity conditions are consistent with summer weather in Korea, which is often very hot and humid. These temperature and humidity conditions are also consistent with a death cited in an earlier article critical of fan death, which suggested that fan use was irrelevant.[3]

Texts on industrial hygiene and ventilation will describe conditions when the use of a fan will increase a worker's heat load. Those conditions include very high temperatures found in foundries and similar industries like heat treating metals. Similar problems occur with high heat and high humidity.

A 2007 meta-analysis of studies on heat wave-related deaths explains that "a fan induces air movement that increases evaporation and lowers skin temperature, but in warm environments increased wind speeds of hot air can actually raise the skin temperature and thus produce opposite results by increasing core body temperature."[13] The study concludes that definitive recommendations on fan use require further study.

An analysis of risk factors contributing to 700 "excess deaths" during a 1995 Chicago, Illinois, heat wave found no evidence that fans either increased or decreased mortality, but noted that "interpretation of the data on the use of fans is complicated by the need to take into account specific environmental factors (for example, whether the fan is used in a room with an open or a closed window) and the health status of individual subjects."[14] Fear of crime was cited as a factor in people keeping windows and doors locked shut.

Media coverage

In summer, mainstream Korean news sources regularly report on cases of fan death. A typical example is this excerpt from the July 28, 1997, edition of The Korea Herald, an English-language newspaper:

The heat wave which has encompassed Korea for about a week, has generated various heat-related accidents and deaths. At least 10 people died from the effects of electric fans which can remove oxygen from the air and lower body temperatures...

On Friday in eastern Seoul, a 16-year-old girl died from suffocation after she fell asleep in her room with an electric fan in motion. The death toll from fan-related incidents reached 10 during the past week. Medical experts say that this type of death occurs when one is exposed to electric fan breezes for long hours in a sealed area. "Excessive exposure to such a condition lowers one's temperature and hampers blood circulation. And it eventually leads to the paralysis of heart and lungs," says a medical expert.

"To prevent such an accident, one should keep the windows open and not expose oneself directly to fan air," he advised.

Published professional opinion

Dr. Lawrence Kalkstein, a professor of biometeorology at University of Miami and former president of the International Society of Biometeorology, [said in an interview]:

"When the room temperature is high and the fan is on in an enclosed room, the room's heat becomes concentrated on the person and causes the body temperature to rise. As the breeze from the fan takes away body fluids from the exposed skin, it could lead to death."[15]

Gord Giesbrecht, a professor of thermophysiology at the University of Manitoba in Canada,[16] is a leading expert on hypothermia:

It's hard to imagine death by fan, because to die of hypothermia, one's body temperature would have to get down to 28 [°C], drop by 10 degrees [Celsius] overnight. We've got people lying in snowbanks overnight here in Winnipeg and they survive. Maybe if someone was elderly and they were sitting there for three days in a sealed room with an electric fan turned on. Someone is not going to die from hypothermia because their body temperature drops two or three degrees overnight; it would have to drop eight to ten degrees." In addition, "the only way to verify whether someone had really died of hypothermia during the night would be to take a core body temperature the following morning. Waiting three days while the body was in the morgue wouldn't work because the corpse's temperature can drop during that time.[2]

Dr. John Linton at Yonsei's Severance Hospital, who attended medical school at Yonsei University, is licensed to practice medicine in South Korea:[2]

There are several things that could be causing the fan deaths, things like pulmonary embolisms, cerebrovascular accidents or arrhythmia. There is little scientific evidence to support that a fan alone can kill you if you are using it in a sealed room. Although it is a common belief among Koreans, there are other explainable reasons for why these deaths are happening.

Dr. Lee Yoon-song is a professor at Seoul National University's medical school and works with the school's Institute of Scientific Investigation. He has conducted autopsies on some of the people who have been described in Korean media as having succumbed to fan death:

When someone's body temperature drops below 35 degrees, they do start to lose judgment ability. So if someone was hiking and later found dead, that could be part of the reason. But we can't really apply this to fan accidents. I found most of the victims already had some sort of disease like heart problems or serious alcoholism. So hypothermia is not the main reason for death, but it may contribute.

He blames the Korean media for the persistence of the urban legend:

Korean reporters are constantly writing inaccurate articles about death by fan, describing these deaths as being caused by the fan. That's why it seems that fan deaths only happen in Korea, when in reality these types of deaths are quite rare. They should have reported the victim's original defects such as heart or lung disease, which are the main cause of death in these cases. If a Western doctor investigated these deaths, he would say what really caused the death, and say that a fan was beside the victim.

See also

References

  1. ^ Korea Consumer Protection Board (KCPB) (2006-07-18). "Beware of Summer Hazards!". Press release. http://english.cpb.or.kr/user/bbs/code02_detail.php?av_jbno=2006071800002. Retrieved 2007-09-01. 
  2. ^ a b c d Surridge, Grant. (2004-09-22). "Newspapers fan belief in urban myth." JoongAng Daily, via joongangdaily.joins.com and archive.org. Retrieved on 2007-08-30.
  3. ^ a b c Adams, Cecil (1997-09-12). ""Will sleeping in a closed room with an electric fan cause death?"". The Straight Dope. Chicago Reader, Inc.. http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a970912.html. Retrieved 2007-08-02. 
  4. ^ Watanabe, Toshifumi, and Masahiko Morita. (1998-08-31). "Asphyxia due to oxygen deficiency by gaseous substances." Forensic Science International, Volume 96, Issue 1, Pages 47-59. Retrieved on 2007-09-06.
  5. ^ a b Gill, James R., Susan F. Ely, and Zhongxue Hua. (2002). "Environmental Gas Displacement: Three Accidental Deaths in the Workplace." The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology, 23(1):26 –30, 2002. Retrieved on 2007-09-06.
  6. ^ "Concentrated Carbon Dioxide in Western Pennsylvania." The Pittsburgh Geological Society. Retrieved on 2007-09-06.
  7. ^ (2005-11-25). "Chemical Fact Sheets: Carbon Dioxide (CO2)." Wisconsin Department of Health & Family Services. Retrieved on 2007-09-06.
  8. ^ (April 1999). "Safety & Health Bulletin: Protecting Workers From the Acute Effects of Carbon Dioxide Fire Extinguishing Systems Introduction." DOE/EH-0196, Issue 99-1, Office of Occupational Safety and Health Policy, U.S. Department of Energy. Retrieved on 2007-09-06.
  9. ^ "Chapter 3: Housing" Everyday Korean Life, Korea Local Authorities Foundation for International Relations (KLAFIR). Retrieved on 2007-09-06.
  10. ^ Korea Consumer Protection Board (KCPB) (2006-07-18). "Beware of Summer Hazards!". Press release. http://english.cpb.or.kr/user/bbs/code02_detail.php?av_jbno=2006071800002. Retrieved 2007-09-01. 
  11. ^ a b Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. "Heat-related illnesses, deaths, and risk factors—Cincinnati and Dayton, Ohio, 1999, and United States, 1979-1997." The Journal of the American Medical Association, 2000;284(1):34-35, via jama.ama-assn.org. Retrieved on 2007-09-03.
  12. ^ "Tips for Preventing Heat-Related Illness." (Website). "Emergency Preparedness & Response," Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, United States Department of Health and Human Services, 2006-08-15. Retrieved on 2007-09-03.
  13. ^ Bouchama, Abderrezak, Mohammed Dehbi, Gamal Mohamed, Franziska Matthies, Mohamed Shoukri, Bettina Menne. 2007. "Prognostic Factors in Heat Wave–Related Deaths: A Meta-analysis." Archives of Internal Medicine 2007;167:(doi:10.1001/archinte.167.20.ira70009), early release article (2007-08-13) via ama-assn.org. Retrieved on 2007-09-03.
  14. ^ Semenza, J.C., C.H. Rubin, K.H. Falter, et al. 1996. "Heat-related deaths during the July 1995 heat wave in Chicago". New England Journal of Medicine, 1996;335(2):84-90. Retrieved on 2007-09-03.
  15. ^ http://article.joins.com/article/article.asp?total_id=3242070&ctg=1200
  16. ^ 2005-09-07. "Fall 2005 Curriculum (Archive), Learning Series Session (Sept. 21, 2005): Keep Your Head Up: A Primer on Cold Water Immersion and Near-Drowning." (Website). Smartrisk Navigator. Retrieved on 2007-09-01.

External links








Got something to say? Make a comment.
Your name
Your email address
Message